I remember it like it was yesterday. This one afternoon in late spring…THE afternoon. The one that sticks in my memory more than any other day of my life. It still brings a smile to my face thinking about it now, years later.
I was sixteen years old. I’d just finished my junior year of high school. I’d never been super popular with girls, though I did alright with the other guys in school and had a few buddies I used to hang out with. I was an average kid in every way – average height, average build, average grades. Until the summer I turned sixteen, when I had a growth spurt. But not in my height. My voice finally stopped cracking and almost overnight my thoroughly average dick grew to an incredible eight inches. Nothing else grew, though. I didn’t get any taller, or any more muscular. So there I was, an average kid with an above-average cock.
When we’d shower after gym class, the other guys would rag on my about the python between my legs. They gave me a hard time about it but I knew they were talking shit because they were jealous of my size. Even though they were all the same age or older than me, none of them even came close to my size. Not that I looked, of course. But when you’ve got twenty naked dudes in a communal shower, it’s hard not to notice these things.
Slowly but surely word got around about what I was packing in my shorts. Like I said, I’d never been very good with girls, mostly because I’d always been rather shy, but all of a sudden I started getting more and more attention from them. It didn’t really amount to much – despite the contents of my pants I was still really shy around girls – but I did manage to lose my virginity to a cheerleader, a cute little 18-year-old blonde senior who was a classmate of my sister Jennifer. I was pretty proud of myself until I realized that she was the school slut and had already banged almost every guy except me. Well, I consoled myself, at least I got in before the chess club.
One afternoon in early summer, when the weather was just starting to get hot, my parents went out shopping for the day. They’d left me with instructions to mow the lawn while they were out. I got to it, eventually taking my shirt off because it was so hot out. My sister was hanging out in the house with her two friends, Kelly and Gina. Somehow, Jen always got out of doing chores. Daddy’s little girl or something stupid like that. I grumbled about being stuck doing all the crap work while Jen got to hang out with her friends as I finished mowing the lawn.
I put the lawnmower away and went into the house. I heard music from upstairs. I threw my shirt over my shoulder and grabbed a bottle of water from the fridge, then went upstairs. I went past Jen’s room to my own and flopped down on the bed to rest. Then there was a knock at my door.
“Yeah?”
The door opened. My sister’s friend Kelly stuck her head in. “Jake, your sister wants you,” she said.
“What does she want?”
“I dunno,” she said. She tried to hide her giggle but wasn’t exactly successful. “She just said to get you.”
“Ugh,” I grunted. “Fine.”
I got up and went into my sister’s room. Kelly had taken up a perch on the bed, next to my sister and Gina. The three of them looked at me and Kelly said “Jake, Jenny says you scratched her gold limited edition Nirvana CD.”
“What?” I exclaimed. “I didn’t scratch it. I listened to it twice, how the hell did I scratch it?”
“I don’t know,” said Kelly. “But you borrowed it, and now it has a big scratch in it. And Jenny’s going to tell your parents.”
The CD had been a birthday present. My parents would be pissed.
“I’ll buy you a new one,” I said to Jenny.
“How?” said Kelly. She seemed to be the ringleader of their little group. “You don’t have a job.”
“I don’t fucking know, but I’ll get you a new one, I promise.
The three of them looked at each other and smiled. Then they looked at me. “We have a better idea,” said Kelly. “Jenny won’t tell your parents, if…” Her voice trailed off.
“If what?”
“Well,” said Kelly, shifting position and folding her legs underneath her, “we’ve heard…rumors…about you at school.” Uh-oh, I thought. Kelly continued. “About what you’ve got between your legs. And we wanna see it.”
Oh shit, I thought to myself. What the fuck am I gonna do now? I don’t want to whip out my cock in front of my sister. But if she told my folks about the CD, I’d be grounded for a week. The girls looked at me expectantly. I sighed.
“Ugh. Fine.”
I dropped my shorts and stepped out of them so I stood in just my boxers. I looked at the three girls sitting on the bed and decided fuck it, if they want a show, I’ll give ’em a show.
I slowly traced a fingertip around the bulge of my cock until it stirred. I rubbed it back and forth through the material of my boxers until I started to get hard. I cupped my hand over it and stroked up and down gently, getting harder and harder, until the tip of my cock peeked out through the waistband. I gripped my cockhead in my fist and pulled down like a lever, pushing my boxers down so they fell to my ankles. Then I removed my hand and stood there in all my glory, my erect cock pointing up at the girls.
The three of them sat there with their mouths wide open in awe. There was no way three hot seventeen year old girls had never seen a naked cock before, but I had a feeling none of the had ever seen something like what I was showing them. “Holy fuck,” said Gina, the first words she’d said so far. “It’s fucking huge.” My sister tried not to stare but she was a seventeen year old girl faced with an eight inch dick; she couldn’t look away if she wanted to. And Kelly…Kelly stared at my pole hungrily. “I want it,” she said. She moved to grab my dick. Gina stopped her.
“Wait,” Gina said. “I have an idea.”
The three of them huddled together whispering. I stood there, patiently waiting to find out what they were up to. My cock began to deflate a little, so I idly stroked it to keep it at full mast. Finally they broke their huddle.
“Jake,” said Kelly, “go wait in the hall for a minute, ok?”
“Um…sure,” I said. I went to pull my shorts up until she said “You can leave those right there.”
So I stepped out into the hallway and waited about two or three minutes until I heard Kelly’s voice call “OK, you can come in now!”
I stepped back into the room to discover the three girls laying on the bed, the blanket over their heads down to their waists. Their hips and legs stuck out from beneath the blanket. They were also bare. They’d all taken their shorts and panties off.
“We’re going to play a game,” came Kelly’s muffled voice from beneath the blankets. “You’re going to try to guess which one of us is which. If you get it right…you get a prize.”
I remember thinking “This is really fucking weird.” But at the same time there were three naked pussies on display before me. I decided that I liked this game. I took in the sight before me and tried to figure out who was who.
Gina was easy to spot. 5’2″ she was the shortest of the three, and her Italian blood gave her long black hair and olive skin. It had also given her a tremendous pair of heavy DD tits, a nice round ass, curvy hips, and thick thighs. Gina’s body drove me wild. If I could have picked one of my sister’s friends to fuck, it would have been Gina. The other two were a little harder to tell apart. One of the pussies was clean-shaven, the other had a little racing stripe of soft dark hair. My sister was a lean, willowy brunette with dark eyes, like our mom. Her body was slender but very nicely shaped, with long sexy legs and small but perky boobs. I’d always thought my sister was beautiful. (So did most of the other guys at school. I’d gotten into more fights defending her than I can even remember.) Kelly was a curvy blonde with a tight ass and a pair of C-cups that sat high on her chest, and amazing bright blue eyes. Of the three Kelly was the prettiest, my sister was the most elegant, and Gina was the sexiest. With my sister’s brunette hair, I was pretty sure the racing stripe was her. I grabbed the blanket and pulled it away.
“Hey, no fair!” yelled Kelly. “You were supposed to guess!” I’d been wrong! The dark racing stripe had been her! My sister was the clean-shaven one!
“Fun game,” I said. I eyed the three naked girls laying on the bed, trying to cover their bodies with their hands. The sight had my cock at full attention. “But I have a game of my own I want to play.”
I ached to get my hands on Gina but decided to save her for later. Kelly had been the instigator of this little game, so I focused on her. I locked my eyes on hers and grabbed her hips. I pulled her up to the edge of the bed as she asked “Wait, what are you…”
Her eyes went wide and she gasped as I knelt beside the bed and went down on her. I held her thighs in my hands as I slipped my tongue in between the lips of her cunt, tasting her sweetness. I reached around and used my thumbs to spread her pussy open, inhaling the scent of her as my tongue lapped up and down her pink slit. She started moaning and her pussy got wetter as I ran my tongue-tip around her clit. I ate Kelly out for a few minutes more, until she started squirming and panting that she was going to cum. Then…I stopped.
I slowly stood, while she stared at me in disbelief. “What the hell, Jake, finish me off! I was about to cum!”
“I know,” I said with a grin. “Don’t worry, you’ll get to. In a minute.”
I turned my attention to Gina. She looked back at me with a mixture of amazement and lust in her eyes. She was the quietest of the three, but I’m pretty sure she knew I had a crush on her. I knelt between her legs and she spread them wide for me, looking at me expectantly. I gazed into her eyes for a moment and then lowered my head between her thighs.
Gina tasted different than Kelly. A bit muskier, more heady, but all the more sensual for it. I drank deep of her sexual aroma as my tongue played around her already wet pussy. I drove my tongue as deep into her as I could, sucking and nibbling her clit. She threw her head back and moaned as my hands roamed over her body, finding their way to her massive tits. I grabbed and squeezed them, caressing and feeling them in my hands the way I’d always wanted to. My cock throbbed and ached and I wanted nothing more than to plunge it into her and blow a huge load of hot cum right inside her. Gina moaned and arched her back, I felt her orgasm coming…
..and I stopped.
I stood. She looked at me with a hurt look on her face. “Jake,” she pouted, “please…”
“In a bit, honey,” I said. “Don’t worry. I’ll take care of you.”
I looked back and forth at the three girls. Kelly was glaring at me, looking annoyed and horny.
She also looked horny.
I looked back at my sister for a minute. Two minutes. Three minutes. Arguments raged inside my head. I’d always thought she was beautiful. She’s my sister. She’s gorgeous. She’s my sister. If she wasn’t my sister…
Then I remembered that one time, about two months before. I’d seen her in the shower while brushing my teeth. I couldn’t stop looking at her. I started to get hard at the sight of my sister lathering her naked body. I booked it out of the bathroom before she realized I was there, then watched through my barely open bedroom door as she went into her room. I snuck over to her doorway and cracked the door just enough to catch a glimpse of her dropping her towel, brushing her hair totally naked…and then laying back on her bed and playing with herself, moaning softly. I’d knelt in the hallway and stroked my dick watching my sister masturbate. I came so hard I’d soaked my shorts.
That made up my mind.
I looked at Jenny and said in a soft voice, “Your turn…”
Her eyes widened but she didn’t say anything. I knelt before her and pulled her to the edge of the bed. “Jake…” she whispered, but didn’t voice any protest as I leaned in and started to lick her.
I ate out my sister’s pussy like I’d done to her friends, licking her up and down, tonguing her pink slit. She tried to push me away but not too hard. Her pussy was wet, juices dribbling down the crack of her ass and down my chin. I licked her around and around, up over and down, until her hips started moving in circles and she gripped me by my hair, pulling me into her snatch. My sister was about to cum.
I stopped.
She stared at me, her eyes wide, panting hard. The other girls gaped at us. A look passed between my sister and I, a look that said nobody would ever find out about this, we could never speak of this to anyone ever.
Without taking my eyes off my sister, I said, “Kelly…”
“What?” she snapped, still annoyed that I hadn’t gotten her off.
I reached over and grabbed her by the hair, tipping her head back. I brought my cock to her mouth. “Suck it,” I said.
Her eyes went wide and so did her mouth. I pushed the tip of my cock between her lips and she started sucking, her little mouth open wide. I fucked Kelly’s pretty face, loving the way her eyes went wide as my huge cock filled her mouth. I reached over, past my sister, and started toying with Gina’s tits. Gina looked up at me and said “I want some!”
I took my cock from Kelly’s mouth and offered it to Gina. She eagerly plunged her mouth down onto me, opening wide and taking as much of me down her throat as she could. She cupped my balls and stroked them as she blew me, my cock throbbing in her mouth. I closed my eyes and reveled in the feeling of something I’d wanted for a long time. But I couldn’t finish now. We still had a game to play out.
I pulled free of Gina’s mouth and turned to my sister. I said nothing. She looked up at me for a moment and then said, in a reflection of what I’d said to her, “Your turn.” She leaned forward and wrapped her lips around my pole.
Jenny was a combination of Kelly and Gina’s styles. She started slow, like Gina had, but then started bobbing her head up and down, fucking my rod with her mouth like Kelly. Then she started swirling her tongue around my cockhead and I ran my fingers through her soft dark hair, closing my eyes and loving the way my sister blew my cock.
I again reached over to Gina, this time pulling her to me. I kissed her deeply, loving the way her big soft tits pressed against my bare chest. She kissed me back eagerly, her tongue swirling in my mouth, then she whispered in my ear, “Jake, I want your cock inside me…”
I looked into her beautiful brown eyes. “You’ll get it, baby, I promise.”
I pulled away from my sister and locked eyes with Kelly. She’d been staring at my sister going down on me, her hand between her legs, fingering herself. She was nice and wet. Good. I moved towards her and she said “What are you going to do now?”
“What do you think?” I answered. I grabbed her thighs and spread them wide. Her eyes went as wide as saucers as she realized that I was going to stick my huge cock into her tiny little pussy. “Oh my GODDDDDDD!!!!” she cried as I pushed my way into…
