The only thing worse than hearing your little sister have sex, is hearing her have sex with the girl you want to have sex with.
After the welcome home party, Alex was unpacking and thinking about what an idiot he was. He couldn’t believe he slipped up and hit on Olivia. “You are not allowed to bang your little sister’s friends,” he said quietly. The mantra was becoming less reassuring and more annoying every time he said it.
Why the hell not, he thought, she’s an adult. I’m an adult. What two consenting adults do is nobody’s damn business. With his mind made up, Alex decided to get closer to Olivia. He knew he couldn’t just hump and dump her, they were going to be in each other’s lives for a long time because of Annie, but he wanted to explore any option that would result in getting closer to her.
That’s when he heard the moaning coming from Annie’s room. At first he thought she was enjoying some “alone time”. Not wanting to listen to his sister get herself off, Alex rummaged through a box looking for his iPod. When he finally found it, it slipped through his fingers and crashed onto the floor.
He heard Olivia’s voice coming from Annie’s room. She was, quite loudly, begging Annie to make her come. He’d made a complete ass of himself. He, pretty poorly, hit on a girl who, not only was into girls, but was also fucking his sister. And he couldn’t get her out of his head. “Well, fuck,” he said quietly.
*~*~*
Alex woke to sun shining through his window and thoughts of last night flooding his mind.
He’d accepted the fact that he wanted Olivia and decided to go for it, only to be disappointed. He swore she was checking him out during the party, but clearly that was all in his head. He was hoping that the work she put in to her appearance that night was for his benefit; he now knew it was for Annie’s. “God, this sucks,” he mumbled to himself.
Alex decided that a good run would get his mind off her. He threw on a tank top and some running shorts and headed downstairs. He was hoping to avoid Oliva, but when he walked into the kitchen she was there. Suppressing a groan and a blush he mumbled something that sounded like good morning to her.
“Morning, Alex,” she beamed, “would you like some coffee?”
“No thanks. I’m just grabbing some water before my run,” he informed her.
“Oh a run sounds great! I’ll come with you,” she said, while practically bouncing upstairs, presumably to change.
“Great,” sulked Alex.
*~*~*
Via was ecstatic to spend some alone time with Alex. Her night with Annie had taken a bit of the edge off, but she knew Annie was right; she had to tell Alex how she felt.
As the pair headed out of the house, Alex didn’t say anything to Via. He set a hard pace, and Via found it difficult to keep up. He never once talked to her or looked to see if she was still behind him. Via started to wonder if she’d imagined their chemistry last night.
They finished their long, punishing run almost forty minutes later at a large park near the house. They stopped in a shaded area of the grass to do cool off stretches. Via took the opportunity to ask Alex what was wrong.
“Hey, Alex,” Via panted, still out of breath from running, “did I do something to upset you?”
“No,” came his flat reply.
His answer made Via angry. She knew he was upset, and she was going to find out why. “Don’t bullshit me, Alex. I know you’re upset with me over something. I need to know what I did to make you pull a complete 180 on me. Last night I felt like… well, like you maybe kind of liked me, but today you’re cold,” Via rambled.
Alex turned to her sharply. How dare she mention that she thought he liked her when she clearly had no interest in him. “So what if I did,” he snapped. “Why does it matter at all how I feel towards you? You have a girlfriend.” He watched confusion cloud her features. Suddenly she looked embarrassed. She blushed deeply.
“I don’t have a girlfriend, Alex,” Via practically whispered.
“Now who’s bullshitting who? I heard you last night,” Alex said, pain written all over his face.
“Oh, Alex,” Via almost giggled. “What you heard was two friends messing around. That’s all. Annie has a boyfriend, and well…” Via looked down, suddenly very interested in her running shoes.
Alex couldn’t believe how happy her words made him. Her blushing shyness made him even more ecstatic. Maybe she did actually like him. Maybe he still had a shot. He walked up to her and lifted her chin. “Well what, sweetheart,” Alex coaxed.
Sweetheart? Via’s heart leapt into her throat when he called her that. “Well, I like you too. I’ve had the biggest crush on you for a really long time,” she blurted out, hoping to get it over with quickly.
Via waited for his reply, dreading it, but a reply didn’t come. Alex leaned down and softly placed his lips on hers. The kiss took Via by surprise, but she soon found herself standing on her tip toes, wrapping her arms around his neck, and pulling her body towards his. Alex groaned and placed one hand on her neck and one on her lower back, pulling her closer still.
The kiss was sweet and unhurried. Alex held Via close and was rubbing his thumb in circles around her neck. As their tongues danced, Via had a hard time wrapping her head around the fact that this was actually happening. Just then, Alex moved his hand under Via’s tank top to place it on her naked back. It was a harmless touch, but it was still enough to startle Via out of the kiss. Only Annie had ever touched her, and this felt different, much different.
His hands still on her neck and back, Alex searched Via’s eyes for an answer to why she pulled back. She looked frightened, like a deer about to collide with a truck. “Too fast,” Alex asked. Via nodded her head. Alex removed the hand from Via’s shirt and brought both hands up to cradle her face, slowly stroking her cheeks. “It’s okay,” he reassured her. “I got a little carried away, especially for being in public.”
“I… I’m sorry,” Via stammered, “It’s just I’ve never… I mean… with a guy.”
Via’s face was bright red, and although Alex was a little shocked to hear that Via had never been with a man, only compassion and patience showed on his face.
“Okay,” came her meek reply.
*~*~*
When they got back to the house, Alex and Via found a note from Alex’s parents stating that they were headed out for the day. Church, lunch, then shopping. The usual. Via picked up her phone from the counter and saw she had a text from Annie:
Hey you, way to make a girl wake up alone. Bad form. You’re lucky you’re good in bed. I’m spending the day with Liam. Maybe the night too. Cover for me. xox
Via looked up at Alex. “Annie went to her boyfriend’s,” she informed him.
“To make up for cheating on him,” Alex asked wryly.
“No,” Via snapped, offended. “Liam knows. He knows that this is something Annie and I have been doing every once in a while for a long time. He respects that it’s part of our friendship.”
“Calm down, Olivia,” Alex said softly, “I was only joking. I’m sorry.”
Via started to tell him it was okay when she realized something. “Did you just call me by my actual name?” she asked.
“Yeah, I guess I did,” Alex said, a little surprised himself. “Come on let’s go watch a movie.”
After separate, very cold, showers, the pair decided to watch a movie in Alex’s room so they could lay on his bed and relax. As soon as the movie started, Via kind of regretted it. She could feel his presence beside her, and the urge to touch him was strong. Being around him was frustrating, sexually, and the way that he was clear about not wanting to push her boundaries made her want to push them.
Out of nowhere, as if he could read her mind, Alex said, “I feel it too.” He turned to look at her and grabbed hold of her hand. Via blushed “Don’t be nervous around me,” he said. “I just want us to get to know each other better.”
After the movie finished, Alex went to get up, but Via pulled back on his hand to stop him. “Wait,” she said. “While I don’t think I’m ready to do some things with you, there are some things I’d really like to do.”
Alex was caught by surprise. What did she mean by that? “What kind of things?” he asked, stroking her hand with his thumb. Via started to undo Alex’s belt then she popped open the button of his jeans. She had his zipper half way down when he finally was able to speak. “Wait, Olivia. What are you doing?” he asked.
“I’m going to suck your cock,” she said calmly.
Alex couldn’t believe it. A few hours ago placing his hand on her back scared her away, but now she was talking about his cock like it and her were old friends. “Olivia, you don’t have to…” he started, but she interrupted him.
“I want to,” she said, determination in her eyes. Seeing that he wasn’t going to stop her, Via finished opening up Alex’s jeans and pulled them down, along with his boxers, to his thighs. What she saw shocked her.
She’d never seen a penis before, not in person at least. It was big, really big, and it looked painfully hard. Via reached out to lightly stroke it. She ran her hand from the bottom to the top, flicking her fingers over the head as they passed it. Alex shuddered at that. “Did that feel good?” she asked.
“Honey, I’m sure anything done by you would feel good,” he said, a little breathless.
“I like it when you call me sweetheart and honey,” she said, looking Alex in the eye, “and beautiful.”
Via had watched plenty of porn, so she felt she had some sort of idea of how to please Alex. She stroked his cock, wrapping her hand around it and holding it lightly, until precum started to ooze out the top. Curious, Via bent down and flicked her tongue over the tip to taste him. Alex practically growled when Via’s tongue made contact. She looked up to see his eyes watching her, affection plastered all over his face. Via smiled and lowered her mouth over his cock, not breaking eye contact until Alex closed his.
Via started slowly filling her mouth with Alex’s cock. It tasted good. It tasted like him. When she went too low, she realized she didn’t have the gag reflex of a porn star and wrapped her hand around the base of Alex’s cock to make up for it. Via slowly slid her mouth up and down Alex’s shaft, swirling her tongue over the top when she reached it.
“Faster, baby,” Alex panted. Via picked up speed but kept the same pattern of sliding her mouth up and licking around his head before sliding back down.
Via’s knees and mouth started to get sore, but she didn’t care. Alex was starting to make little half-moan, half-growls, and she really enjoyed pleasing him. Alex had his hands in Via’s hair, not controlling her movements, just holding on for the ride. Suddenly his fingers clutched her hair tightly and he growled through clenched teeth, “Baby, I’m going to come. If you don’t want it in your mouth, you better stop.”
Via did want him to come in her mouth, even more so now that he cared enough to warn her. She doubled her efforts, sucking on Alex’s cock a little harder and moving a little faster. A loud moan escaped Alex’s lips, and rope after rope of warm, salty cum landed in Via’s mouth. She was surprised how much she liked the taste of his cum. She quickly swallowed every drop that he gave her.
After Alex’s breathing returned to normal, Via slid up his body and kissed him. Alex wrapped his arms around her and deepened the kiss, trying to show her just how much he appreciated what she just did.
Via broke the kiss and slid off Alex to lay on the bed beside him. She watched as he tucked his still-impressively large cock back into his boxers and jeans.
When he was done, he turned to Via and slowly stroked her cheek with the back of his hand. “That was amazing,” Alex said with wonder in his eyes. “Thank you.”
“I really enjoyed it,” Via said blushing, “like, a lot!”
Alex looked Via in the eyes and hoped that what he said next wouldn’t scare her away. “Can I,” he started letting out a loud breath, “can I possibly return the favour?”
