I was excited to be going to my first college party but I was nervous too. Ashley had picked out my clothes. To be fair about it, she was dressed almost the same as me. We were both wearing tight cut-off jeans that were so short the bottom of our ass cheeks showed. She had cut out the pockets so skin showed through all four pocket holes. She did give me a little black thong to wear under it. For my shirt I had a tight yellow crop top. She told me I would be better off without a bra. You could see the dark color of nipples through the shirt. I told her I couldn’t wear it out in public without a bra. She told me it would be dark and no one would notice. After I got dressed I told her people were going to see my nipples. It would be light in the house. She just asked me who was the bigger slut. I said she was and she told me not for long.
The party was only a couple of blocks away so we walked. When we got there they handed us each a beer. I was 18 and had only tasted beer a couple of times. I knew I couldn’t drink much. I talked to a lot of guys and danced a little. I was embarrassed by all the guys paying so much attention to me. They weren’t interested in talking really. They were mostly just looking at me and taking every chance they got when we were dancing to grab my ass or rub against my tits. After my second beer I was feeling less self conscience. We had been there a couple of hours when one of the senior girls (Jennifer) said it was time to play a game. She had everyone sit down facing her then announced we were going to play “Guess Whose Cock.”
There were cheers from all the guys and a lot of the girls. A few of us had no idea what was about to happen. A girl sitting on the couch volunteered to be first. She went over to Jennifer and got on her knees. A blindfold was placed on her and then she said she was ready. One guy got up and stood by her and pulled out his cock. Jennifer took her hand and placed it on the guy’s cock. She started jacking him for what seemed like a long time to me. Jennifer asked her to guess whose cock it was and she said Billy. Everyone cheered. She had guessed right. She pulled off the blindfold and kissed the tip of his cock then helped him put it back in his pants. I figured out that he was her boyfriend. Another girl jumped up and kneeled in front of Jennifer. After she was wearing the blindfold, her hand was placed on a guys cock. She jacked him for a while then guessed David. Everyone yelled “strike one.” Another guy came up and she jacked him. When it was time to guess she said Larry. Everyone cheered. She pulled off her blindfold and stood up and kissed him while stroking his cock a few more times.
When they said whose next Ashley jumped up. She got into position and put on the blindfold. After jacking the first guy and making her guess, everyone yelled strike one. Then there was strike two. After strike three she thought she was done.
Jennifer said, “You’re not done yet. That’s just the first strike. You play topless now.”
Ashley looked at her for a second then pulled off her shirt. Jennifer put the blindfold back on her and helped her to her knees.
She said, “For this out you have to take them in your mouth. If you guess right on the first guy you get your shirt back. If not you stay topless all night.”
Another guy walked up to Ashley and pulled his cock out. He put it on her lips and she sucked in into her mouth. She looked like she was really enjoying herself until Jennifer stopped her and asked for her guess.
“Alan,” she said.
Strike one. After sucking her second cock she guessed Frank. I don’t know how she got it right. She didn’t even know Frank. She came back and sat down between two guys. They immediately started playing with her tits.
Jennifer was looking right at me and said “Who wants to be next? How about you Red?”
Ashley started chanting, “Lindsey, Lindsey, Lindsey.”
Everyone joined in the chant so I got up and kneeled in front of Lindsey. I didn’t know any of these guys. My mind was blank. I couldn’t remember names. I didn’t know what I was going to do. Jennifer asked if I was ready. I told her I guess so.
Then I heard her say, “Randy quit getting yourself ready. You have to follow the rules.”
She leaned down and whispered that he was jacking himself because he wanted to cum on me. I knew right then what I was going to do. My hand was placed on the first cock. It was hard. Before even jacking it I yelled out Randy.
Everyone laughed then yelled strike one.
The guy said “She broke the rules. She’s supposed to jack me for a whole minute before she guesses. Isn’t there some kind of penalty?”
Jennifer said, “You’re right Verlon. She has to jack you until you cum and its two minutes for each cock now.”
I tried to protest that I didn’t know about the one minute rule but it was no use. I jacked Verlon for several minutes. I knew when he was about to cum. He grabbed his cock away from me and aimed at my face. I was glad for the blindfold. It kept it out of my eyes. Plus I really didn’t want to see everyone’s faces right now.
I jacked the next cock for what seemed like forever. Finally Jennifer asked for my guess and I said Randy again. Strike two. The third cock wasn’t Randy either and I lost my top.
After the first cock I sucked for two minutes wasn’t Randy, I knew I was topless for the night. Strike two wasn’t Randy either. When Jennifer told me to guess cock three, the guy grabbed my head and fucked my mouth for a few more seconds until he let go in my mouth. He wasn’t letting go so I had to swallow it all down. After he released me I said Randy. Strike three.
“That’s two outs,” Jennifer said. “Stand up babe and let me help you out of your shorts.”
I couldn’t believe I was being stripped in front of all these people I didn’t know. I was so embarrassed. I stood and felt her unfasten my cut-offs and slide them down my legs. I lifted my feet one at a time so I could step out of them.
Then she said, “This thong has to go too.”
I felt her pulling it then I heard a snap.
“Oops,” she said. “I guess you won’t be wearing that any more.”
She told me to get on my hands and knees. I asked what was going to happen now and she said they were going to fuck me. She had me spread my legs a little then fingered me to make sure I was ready. She called for the first guy. I felt him get behind me and rub his cock up and down my slit. Then he just pushed it in and started fucking me. Slowly at first then he started going fast and hard. When Jennifer said two minutes were up he didn’t stop. He just kept fucking me. It felt so good I didn’t try to stop him. He grabbed my hips and pushed hard into me. He was so deep and it felt so good. I could feel his cock grow and start erupting into me. I just pushed back as hard as I could. When he finally stopped and pulled out, Jennifer asked who it was. Randy was my answer. Strike one. I would be naked for the rest of the party. Knowing I was going to be exposed to all the hands that wanted to try something that night just made me wetter.
The second guy to fuck me wasn’t Randy either. He didn’t cum in me. He pulled out and came on my ass. The next guy said he wasn’t going to fuck me until the cum was cleaned off my ass. Jennifer asked who wanted to help. Then she called Cathy and Lori. The next thing I knew there were two tongues licking cum off my ass. One of them started playing with my pussy. I’m not sure how many fingers she was using to fuck me. The other one started pushing against my asshole. Before I really knew what was happening, she had a finger in me and was fucking my ass. These two girls kept this up until they made me cum. Then I heard a guy say he was ready to go. They got out of the way and I felt him get behind me and guide his cock into my used pussy.
It felt so good lost track of time. When he finally came, Jennifer said it was eight minutes.
I said, “I thought it was just supposed to be two minutes.”
She said everyone including me was enjoying it so much she let him keep going. Then she asked me my guess.
Everyone there yelled “Randy.”
She asked if that was my guess and I said yes.
Everyone yelled “Strike three. You’re out.”
Jennifer took off the blindfold and had me stand facing everyone. There was dried cum on my face and cum running down my legs. She asked if I would like to play the bonus round. I asked what that was.
She said. “One more guy. He gets your ass. If you guess right you get your clothes back now. If you guess wrong, you go home tonight naked.”
Everyone was telling me to go for it. I finally said I would. She put the blindfold on me and had me get on my hands and knees. The guy got behind me and said he was going to go into my pussy first to lube it up. He did a couple of strokes then pulled out and placed the tip on my asshole. I tried to relax and he started to push. At first it didn’t want to go in but my ass finally opened a little and he pushed in. He took his time working his way deeper and deeper. Finally he was all the way in. After I got used to it he started fucking me. It hurt but it felt so good. The longer he did it the less it hurt. It didn’t take him long before he grabbed my hips and pushed in deep. He felt so big and so good filling me up like that. After he came he leaned on my back and rested. Jennifer asked me to make a guess. I was exhausted.
“Richie,” I said.
Everyone died laughing.
Jennifer said, “Lindsey hun, that was Randy.”
Ashley and I stayed at the party for a couple of more hours. Her tits were red from all the guys pinching them. I had gone up and taken a shower after the game. After I came back down I got a lot of attention from a lot of hands. When we got ready to leave, Ashley was told to go stand on the front porch and she could have her shirt. She walked out of the house topless and had to stand there a couple of minutes before they gave it to her. She slipped in on and we started heading home. I tried to stay in the shadows so I wouldn’t be seen. I was out in the open under a bright light for the final 30 yards before we got in the dorm.
Standing on the front porch with her hand on the door, Ashley turned to me and said, ”Who’s the bigger slut?”
I looked at her and said, “I am.”
