John didn’t speak for the rest of the night. Evan and I barely said a word either. It was the hottest, most intense sex I’d ever had, and I was already hoping it wouldn’t be the last time. A couple of hours later, John got up and went to bed. Evan headed to his own room, and I slipped into mine, falling asleep almost instantly. After all, the three of us had been straight just two days ago—and John had been straight only three hours earlier.
The next morning, I woke up to the sound of laughter. Evan and John were sitting at the kitchen table eating breakfast, talking and joking like nothing had happened. When they noticed me, John grinned and Evan burst out laughing. I stood there, completely confused.
“What the hell, guys?” I asked.
“Nothing. Sit down,” John said, chuckling to himself.
I took the chair next to him. Before I could say anything else, John leaned in and kissed me on the lips. I stared at him, dumbfounded.
“We want you to be both of our boyfriend,” Evan added.
I looked at Evan, still confused. “We both want to be with you,” he continued. “And we want to be with each other too.”
My cheeks burned bright red. “Are you serious?”
“Yeah,” they both said in unison.
I looked at both of them, then walked over to John and climbed onto his lap as seductively as I could. I leaned down and kissed him deeply, our tongues wrestling. Evan stood up and walked over. I reached for his waistband, pulling down his pants as John licked and sucked on my neck. I freed Evan’s beautiful cock and started stroking it. Evan leaned down to kiss me, and then I gently pushed their heads together. They started kissing right in front of me.
“Oh my God, that’s so hot,” I moaned, watching my two boyfriends make out.
They broke their kiss. John kissed me, then Evan, then back to John. Someone— I’m not sure who—ripped my shirt off, and soon both of them were sucking on my nipples while I held their heads gently. Evan pulled my shorts down, revealing my hard cock. They both dropped to their knees and started sucking me together, their mouths working the sides of my shaft all the way to the tip.
John swallowed my head while Evan sucked and licked my balls. “Ohhh my God!” I yelled.
They lifted me onto the table. Evan wrapped his lips around my cock while John spread my cheeks and shoved his tongue inside me. I gripped the edges of the table, my head hanging off the other side as these two gorgeous men worshipped my body. Evan moved up and shoved his cock down my throat. His hands gripped my head as he thrust deep, making me choke and gag. Moments later, I felt John’s lubed cock pressing against my ass. He pushed in slowly while Evan held his cock deep in my throat, his balls resting on my eyes.
Evan pulled out so I could gasp for air as John sank deeper. I moaned loudly, grabbing Evan’s wet cock and stroking it while I stroked myself. John’s hands gripped my waist as he fucked me, his sexy moans filling the room. They took turns in my mouth and ass, then fucked me in unison. Evan pinched and rubbed my nipples. The pleasure was overwhelming.
Suddenly, I started cumming hard, squirting all over myself. My ass clenched around John’s cock. He kissed Evan passionately as he filled me up. Evan pulled out and shot across my face. I grabbed his cock and cleaned him up, sucking on his sensitive head. “Mmm, fuck, you taste so good,” I moaned.
“God damn, that was incredible,” John said, breathing hard.
Evan leaned down and kissed me, smearing his cum between our faces. John joined in, licking some of my cum and kissing me too. They helped me up and we headed to the bathroom, John’s load leaking down my legs and Evan’s cum still covering my face.
The next couple of weeks were a blissful blur of threesomes. Some nights I’d fuck Evan while John watched, other nights I’d take John. One evening I watched the two of them fuck each other—it was incredibly hot. We bought a king-size bed so we could all sleep together. Waking up every morning wrapped in their arms was pure heaven.
It had been about a month since Evan and I first fooled around. I got home from work late one night and found Evan and John sitting on the couch in just their boxers. Two muscular, gorgeous men with huge cocks, all waiting for me.
“Hey, boys!” I called out as I walked in.
“Hey, hun!” they yelled back in unison.
“What are you two up to?” I asked.
“Not much,” Evan said.
“We have a couple of gifts for you,” John added with a grin.
“Ooooh, I love gifts!” I dropped my bag and practically skipped over. Two gift bags sat on the coffee table.
“Go ahead, open them,” Evan said.
I pulled out the first item: lacy black lingerie. “Oh my God! You guys want me to wear this?”
“Fuck yes,” John said. “We’ve been talking. That gorgeous ass, those thick thighs, and that smooth dick of yours would look so fucking hot in lingerie.”
My cheeks turned bright red. “You guys are so sweet,” I laughed.
The second bag held a small vibrator and a cock cage. “It’s a butt plug,” John explained. “Evan and I will be able to control it while you’re at work. We want you to wear it. And the cage too.”
“You’re gonna put it all on right now,” Evan said. “Then we’re taking you out to dinner. It’s our one-month anniversary. After that, we’re coming home and fucking you like you’ve never been fucked before.”
My heart raced. “I can’t fucking wait.”
I stripped right there. They stood up and circled me, their hands exploring my body as I slipped into the lingerie. Their hungry gazes made me feel incredibly desired. John bent me over the arm of the couch while Evan slid the plug into my ass. I moaned as he smacked my ass hard. “Good boy,” he said.
My cheeks flushed again. Looking down, I whispered, “Baby… do you like being called a good boy?”
“Yes,” I admitted softly.
Evan pulled me in for a kiss. “You’re our good boy. You know that.”
“Yes, Daddy,” I replied.
I looked at John. “Come to Daddy,” he said, kissing me deeply. He struggled a little to get the cage on my hard cock, but with some lube from his mouth, he locked me up. He grabbed his phone and turned the vibrator on.
“Oh shit!” My knees buckled, and I gripped the couch. “Ohhh yes…” He turned it off and smacked my ass again. “Get dressed, honey. Something nice.”
“Yes, Daddy.”
We went to a nice steakhouse. As soon as the waiter approached, the vibrator buzzed to life. I tightened up, barely managing to order water. The guys grinned and laughed as the waiter walked away.
“You guys are assholes,” I whisper-yelled.
“You love it,” Evan teased.
“Yeah… maybe I do.”
Dinner was delicious. On the drive home, John drove while Evan and I made out heavily in the back. I pulled out Evan’s cock and stroked it, then dropped down to suck him. John stroked himself while driving, barely paying attention to the road. Evan turned the vibrator on again, making me moan around his thick cock.
When we parked, John couldn’t wait. He pulled me out of the car, bent me over, and buried his face in my ass while I kept sucking Evan. Then John stood up and thrust into me. Evan kissed me passionately. “I love you, Rog,” he whispered.
I looked into his eyes. “I love you too, Evan.”
John fucked me harder. “I love you too, honey,” he whispered in my ear. Tears of overwhelming emotion filled my eyes as the two men I loved confessed their feelings while taking me.
They swapped, then John lifted me against the car and bounced me on his cock. Evan fed him my leaking precum. The pleasure was insane.
“Can we try both of you inside me?” I begged.
“Yeah,” John said eagerly.
“Fuck yes,” Evan agreed.
They worked together, slowly stretching me open. The mix of pain and pleasure was overwhelming. Once Evan was fully inside, they started fucking me together, their cocks rubbing against each other.
“Fuck, it feels so good feeling your cock against mine,” John moaned.
“Oh my God,” I cried out as they destroyed my ass in the most incredible way. Evan came first, flooding me. The sensation pushed me over the edge—I squirted through the cage all over John. He pounded me harder using Evan’s cum as lube and filled me up too, his grip on my waist bruisingly tight.
They plugged me back up, and we drove home, falling asleep in each other’s arms.
